In this episode of The Orita Podcast, Aaron Schwartz sits down with Amy Carr, Co-Founder of Wine by hOurs. Amy is a former CMO & CDO at ThirdLove, ex-Sephora and Gap Inc. who blends operator experience, financial discipline, and a deeply human approach to building brands.

Amy’s career isn’t a ladder, it’s “a jungle gym across multiple playgrounds,” spanning finance, ecommerce, CRM, and brand-building at some of the most iconic companies in retail. That perspective leads to a clear point of view: great marketing isn’t just creative, it’s accountable, measurable, and rooted in understanding both the customer and the P&L.

Together, they dive into:

• Why a financial background can make you a better marketer and why most overlook it

• The balance between creativity and profitability in modern marketing

• Why “sometimes you need to slow down to speed up” and the power of career resets

• How to actually do customer discovery: journey mapping, segmentation, and clarity of message

• The three pillars of marketing budgets: brand, performance, and retention and why they rarely align

• Why retention is getting harder and why performance dollars are creeping into it

• The real role of loyalty: not just rewards, but data, community, and identity

• Why most brands overcomplicate their tech stacks and how to keep it simple

• AI’s real impact: better analytics, faster creative, and a massive unlock for mid-market brands

• Why authentic, human creative will become more valuable (not less) in an AI world

• The shift from SEO to AEO (agent engine optimization) and what it means for discovery

• How ecommerce is changing: fewer websites, more aggregators, and AI-driven shopping journeys

• Why the next generation of marketers must be AI-native and what that means for hiring

This episode is part operator playbook, part career philosophy, and part look into the future of commerce. If you’re building a brand, leading a team, or trying to make sense of how marketing is evolving in the age of AI, Amy brings clarity, honesty, and real-world experience.

👥 Meet the guest

Amy Carr, Founder of Wine by hOurs

🎙 Hosted by

Aaron Schwartz, Co-Founder & Co-CEO at Orita.ai

🎧 Chapters

[00:00] From Accountant to CMO: Amy Carr’s Unconventional Career Path

[03:32] Why Great Marketers Think Like CFOs (and Most Don’t)

[06:19] “Slow Down to Speed Up”: The Career Move Nobody Talks About

[09:11] The Real Fight: Performance vs. Retention (and Who Wins)

[12:07] How Top Brands Actually Understand Customers (Not Guess)

[15:16] The Truth About Marketing Budgets: Brand vs. Performance vs. Reality

[18:24] Why Cutting Brand Spend Will Haunt You Later

[19:58] Loyalty Isn’t Dead—You’re Just Doing It Wrong

[22:58] Your Tech Stack Is Probably Overbuilt (Here’s the Fix)

[26:07] AI Is Changing Marketing Fast—But Not How You Think

[28:54] The Death of Traditional Ecommerce (What Replaces It)

[31:56] Amy’s Hard-Won Advice: Build a Career That Actually Matters

🌐 Check out Orita.ai for more episodes of The Orita Podcast, where we sit down with the most interesting operators, marketers, and founders in e-commerce to talk about what’s working right now. Hosted by the Orita team. Orita uses machine learning to help brands send smarter, more profitable marketing, by figuring out who actually wants to hear from you and when.

🚀 Get your free email audit from Orita, turn segments into superpowers: https://orita.ai

🎧 Listen on Spotify & Apple

📩 Subscribe for more founder‑grade retention intel